TT logo
You are viewing a low-graphics version of this page. Click the headline to view full version:

Call for a critical edition of "Mein Kampf"

Bavaria's copyright expires in 2015

Toytown Germany > Discussion forum > Germany-wide > German news
sarabyrd
“Mein Kampf� (My Struggle) is Hitler’s manifest, written mostly during his imprisonment in Landsberg in 1924. Well, dictated to his faithful secretary Rudolf Hess who did the actual menial task of typing out the long-winded passages of thoughts and philosophy (for lack of a better non-four letter word). After WW II the U.S. government of Bavaria awarded the copyright to the state of Bavaria for 70 years according to German law, and since then Bavaria has sat tight on them, preventing any new editions or research into the original manuscript. In doing so, the government insists, they are respecting the victims of the Holocaust and protecting Jews worldwide. An honorable but narrow-minded attitude.

The book is not allowed to be printed in Germany but that is as far as the copyright goes, any attempts by the State of Bavaria and the Foreign Office to prevent its being published abroad – among others in Israel – have been thwarted. You can also buy it in used book shops, there should be abundant supplies as every couple received a copy on getting married in the Third Reich. But historians are worried that Neo-Nazis will flood the market with cheap editions once the copyright expires, they insist that the only way to deal with the general availability of Hitler’s ideas is to publish a critical edition with annotations, sources and other explanations. Since Hitler himself didn’t bother much with quoting sources or researching them (c’mon, the poor guy was in jail and didn’t have the internet!) the research would be exhaustive and exhausting, lasting an estimated three years. The final product would have to be expensive to cover the costs, not very conducive to making it available to schools or universities.

But Bavaria is not amenable to any scientific arguments. “Mein Kampf� is bad, dangerous and propaganda material and must therefore be kept under lock and key on the poison shelf. Sort of reminds me of the last scene of “Raiders of the Lost Ark� where “specialists� are taking care of the immensely potent relic …

Related topic: Buying Mein Kampf in Germany
Keydeck
QUOTE (sarabyrd @ Apr 24 2008, 10:25 am) *
since then Bavaria has sat tight on them, preventing any new editions or research into the original manuscript.

I don't understand this point. I have a copy of the book at home in English complete with notes, references, refutations and so forth. Have only read about a third of it though as it's bloody painful.
gordonthemoron
Started reading it (in english) but had to give up as it is so badly written. Good cure for insomnia
FuzzyTony
QUOTE (sarabyrd @ Apr 24 2008, 10:25 am) *
You can also buy it in used book shops, there should be abundant supplies as every couple received a copy on getting married in the Third Reich.

Or just read it online for free.
cb6dba
One of my teachers read and said it was perhaps the most boring and badly written book he has ever read.

The sad fact is, the people who would take the message fo the book to heart are also ones that may not have read many books and would not realise that hitler was, actualy, in all realty, writing about a case on constipation he was having at the time.

Add to that, he was not provided with toilet roll, only old newspapers.

Now thats a struggle...
sarabyrd
Courtesy of my boss' son:

MrNosey
Totally agree with everyone who says “Mein Kampf� is bad. Bad in the sense that it is just so damn boring, long-winded, rambling, crazed... I think it's the sort of book any self-respecting neo-nazi would want on their bookshelf to impress their comrades but one which even they, in any moments of right-wing fervour, would struggle to read cover-to cover.
Villager
Buy the audio book:
Serdar Somuncu liest aus dem Tagebuch eines Massenmörders - Mein Kampf. CD . Mein Kampf! [Audiobook] (Audio CD)
This guy is very funny and is worth supporting
You are viewing a low fidelity version of this page. Click to view the full page.