QUOTE (Conquistador @ Apr 14 2008, 10:57 pm)

You know, BTC, my great-grandfather was thrown into jail by the Nazis in 1933 because he was a Jew and a member of the SPD. I have no tolerance whatsoever for political persecution. Perhaps you should review Article V of the Grundgesetz.
QUOTE (Bell the cat @ Apr 14 2008, 11:03 pm)

but the EPI was founded by just such an assortment of experts who also consulted widely and with trade unions. But you just condemned them as 'leftists' as if that meant they should be confined to the outer circle of hell.
I merely note that they are leftists, which is a provable fact. That is your own personal interpretation in the second sentence.
QUOTE (Bell the cat @ Apr 14 2008, 11:03 pm)

whether or not you agree with their political views they are unquestionably a group of intellectuals who should not be dismissed as easily as you seem to think just because they are very slightly left of centre.
That's two expressions of opinion on your part. They certainly aren't slightly left of center within the US politcal spectrum, and since they are Americans, that's the relevant standard. As to whether or not their opinons were dismissed by me, I am justifiably suspicious of the objectivity of their interpretations of economic data given that they are partially funded by labor unions and also given their well-known leftist ideology.
QUOTE (Bell the cat @ Apr 14 2008, 11:03 pm)

So having a leftist relative means you are justified in throwing out the views of any leftist as redundant? I challenge you to find that in the Grundgesetz
From which magic lamp did you conjure that thought? I would say Article V of the Grundgesetz certainly allows me to question the views of others, which is what I did.
As for the point I was making about my great-grandfather, it is simply that I am a German citizen, and thus, yes, I do belong here, regardless of whether or not some other person who claims it's too difficult to get German citizenship likes my opinion on economic issues in my own country (in this case the US) or not. Your comment hints at an intolerance that is incongruent with the values of a free society, e.g.,
freedom of speech. To question my being in a country in which I am a citizen, one in which my ancestors were once persecuted
on political grounds on the basis of a political disagreement wíth me would be, IMHO, most inappropriate.