When I came in Germany I filled in a form and because it didn't had a box for Orthodox I checked the Catholic box (no big difference to me).
I now I will have to pay tax to that damn church but I didn't 'used' a church since I was 16.
I am a scientist not a believer and I want out. How do I do that?
Thanks.
Keydeck
Mar 20 2008, 2:06 pm
Kill a nun. That usually does the trick.
SpiderPig
Mar 20 2008, 2:07 pm
Kill a nun using a strap-on penis...
kathie
Mar 20 2008, 2:08 pm
It depends where in Germany you live. Here in
Bavaria you go to the Standesamt with your passport, pay 31€ and it's done.
How to leave the church in each state
Yeti
Mar 20 2008, 2:09 pm
The Chatolic church has always been hard on scientists.
Edit: Blessed are the correctors of spellings for they have removed a thorn from the toe of their brethern and washed a grain of sand from the eyeball of the universe, or something.
Derekbeggs
Mar 20 2008, 2:11 pm
Funnily enough, my wife did this yesterday, ok it was the evangelische church, but the principle is the same, she went to the standesamt, told them she wanted to deregister from church tax as she didnt want to pay them any more money and besides we are wiccans, paid 31€ and that was that. The guy warned her that she will probably get a phonecall or visit from her local minister to ask why.
sarabyrd
Mar 20 2008, 2:12 pm
QUOTE(SpiderPig @ Mar 20 2008, 2:07 pm)

Kill a nun using a strap-on penis...
Why would she be wearing one of those?
EDIT: Did anyone click on kathie's link and see that there is an advertising banner for a miracle medallion across the top? Just one more reason for resigning.
Deccie
Mar 20 2008, 2:18 pm
QUOTE(kathie @ Mar 20 2008, 2:08 pm)

Here in Bavaria you go to the Standesamt with your passport, pay 31€ [/url]
QUOTE(Derekbeggs @ Mar 20 2008, 2:11 pm)

paid 31€ and that was that.
You have to pay to stop paying an unwanted tax? strange. It is free in
Berlin to deregister.
BattalionBoy
Mar 20 2008, 2:19 pm
So what are you saying pix - you are a Catholic until you have to pay for it. How are you gonna explain that one when you get to the Pearly Gates.
Moonboot
Mar 20 2008, 2:21 pm
can't you claim Kirchensteuer back at the end of the year. think that's what I used to do 'way back when'.
Yeti
Mar 20 2008, 2:28 pm
I have three of those medals lying on my desk right now if anybody wants them.
I was out in Altötting recently on my bike and on the way back I bought petrol in the town as the the B12 back to Munich is an ideal stretch to demonstrate the superiority of the motocycle as a overtaking instrument.
Being lazy and also having headphones in and being in the middle of a Killers song I went in to pay without taking off my helmet. As I walked back out to the bike I was stopped by a rotund old priest, wearing the old style cassock and a biretta. He said hallo and asked me was I a motorcyclist. To set the scene correctly, I am walking towards the only two wheeled vehicle at the petrol station, wearing motorcycle boots, pants, jacket, gloves, helmet and if his deity really can see all, motorcycle underwear. All that was missing was a little warning sticker "may contain motorcycling elements". I just wish that his boss had this grasp of the obvious. Misinterpreting my bemused look of incredulity for the cry of a lost soul in the wilderness he presented me with three holy medals from a bulging purse that must have contained hundreds of the things.
I made it home safely. Make of it what you will. Not sure if all the power of the medals is used up but that is what belief is for.
Call it, friendo.
chavee
Mar 20 2008, 2:33 pm
I take my religion like I take my liquer...in moderation.
QUOTE(Derekbeggs @ Mar 20 2008, 2:11 pm)

Funnily enough, my wife did this yesterday, ok it was the evangelische church, but the principle is the same, she went to the standesamt, told them she wanted to deregister from church tax as she didnt want to pay them any more money and besides we are wiccans, paid 31€ and that was that. The guy warned her that she will probably get a phonecall or visit from her local minister to ask why.
My wife (Ev) did that a couple of years back - I was warned not to join the club when I arrived here many years ago...
I cannot recall her having to pay 31€ (but we are in the poor North).
You (or in our case I) had to continue paying for a number of months (cant remember how many) then that was it. No phone calls no visits...
QUOTE(Moonboot @ Mar 20 2008, 2:21 pm)

can't you claim Kirchensteuer back at the end of the year. think that's what I used to do 'way back when'.
You must be from a different planet
kathie
Mar 20 2008, 2:37 pm
You apparently pay 10€ in Schlieswig-Holstein
Like I said - the poor North.
bidul
Mar 20 2008, 2:46 pm
My boyfriend resigned few months ago, the procedure was very easy - exactly the same as the one mentioned above. But take my advice and think twice before you do this. In our case, few months later, he had to pay the amount once again and visit our local church, etc. as we actually decided to get merried and had to be a member of a church!
Corcaigh
Mar 20 2008, 3:06 pm
You do not have to be a member of a church to get married. You go to your standesamt.
However should you want a church wedding then you have to be a member but then if you want to be a member you should be prepared to pay the membership fees...
Why would you want to get married in a church if you don't believe in what you are doing...
miwild
Mar 20 2008, 3:09 pm
QUOTE(pix @ Mar 20 2008, 2:05 pm)

... I filled in a form and because it didn't had a box for Orthodox I checked the Catholic box ...
You don´t become a member of the Roman Catholic church by erroneously checking a box in a form provided by a
German state authority.
It takes more than that to convert from Orthodoxy to Roman Catholicism ... unless you´re already a member of an
Eastern Catholic or Uniate Church
QUOTE(Corcaigh @ Mar 20 2008, 3:06 pm)

Why would you want to get married in a church if you don't believe in what you are doing...
I ask myself that question about a number of people...
kitkat64
Mar 20 2008, 3:21 pm
All it took for me to want out of the Catholic church taxes was one trip to Rome (and more specifically, the Vatican). Pissed me right off, it did.
What finally turned my wife off was that we were invited to attend "Konfirmation" of the daughter of good friends of our in Hamburg and during the service
my wife realised that the whole rigmarole meant nothing to her - in particular that the family were not church-goers & havn't been back since.
RickMunich
Mar 20 2008, 3:25 pm
It's OK to go out with a nun, as long as you don't get into the habit...
Lifeisabuffet
Mar 20 2008, 3:44 pm
Get a nun pregnant.
parnell
Mar 20 2008, 3:47 pm
I'd like to be an atheist , I just couldn't stand the dour arrogance that seems to come with it.
Moonboot
Mar 20 2008, 3:50 pm
certainly don't fiddle kiddies as this is likely to get you promoted in the catholic church.
Now truly I am a free man

Thanks (for all) answers. I solved it at Rathaus.
I told them I made a mistake when I filled the form (which is true) as I am (was) orthodox.
I have to pay no tax... just a 'Bitte' and a 'Danke schone'.
And the lady who repaired the mistake was barely speaking English. So, no all
Germans are 'grrrrrrr...' when they meet a non-German speakers.
bluedave
Mar 20 2008, 5:15 pm
I've posted before on this subject but here goes . .
I had an Irish gf who was not earning well but paying Church tax and i talked to her and asked why?
She subsequently cancelled it.
About a week later we were treated to a local priest knocking on the door and, upon entry proceeded to give her the hellfire and damnation speech, up to the point that i physically bade hime farewell.
Bunch of knuts to be honest.
Kazalphaville
Mar 20 2008, 5:42 pm
When I was back home, all I had to do was write a letter to the local priest and I got a letter back confirming that I was no longer registered with them.
QUOTE(bluedave @ Mar 20 2008, 5:15 pm)

... upon entry proceeded to give her the hellfire and damnation speech,...
Totally unlike the priests in the UK, how as we all know from
The Titfield Thunderbolt, spend their time rescuing steam railways...
bidul
Mar 20 2008, 7:00 pm
Why would you want to get married in a church if you don't believe in what you are doing...
Well, personally I don't mind paying a tax church because I DO believe in God, but I was wrongly informed by a friend that the church tax in Munich is extremely high (he shown me his bill of 600 euros!) and this made me so terrified we decided to withdraw. Only later did we learn that this sum was colected for many many years as he had always avoided to pay this tax..
bidul
Mar 20 2008, 7:05 pm
You do not have to be a member of a church to get married. You go to your standesamt.
If you want to get married in a church, you have to. At least where I am getting married.
You cannot have your cake and eat it...
thefirelane
Mar 20 2008, 8:06 pm
Yeah, just like if you want to have your reception in a banquette hall, you have to pay your banquette hall tax. And if you want to rent a car for your wedding, you have to pay your car rental tax.
Oh wait, none of these other service providers get special treatment.
pix
Mar 20 2008, 11:57 pm
QUOTE(thefirelane @ Mar 20 2008, 8:06 pm)

you have to pay your car rental tax.
But you don't pay 9% of your income on that stupid car service, month by month. Right?

I am not a believer, but for those who are God SHOULD love you the same, not based on the quantity on money you pay Him.
Or... you think that paying that STUPID tax will buy you a place in heaven?
I never heard a story about Jesus sitting at the door of the Church and forcing those who didn't paid enough to go back home.
I wouldn't like to be part of such a religion.
Be wise and open minded. Church is nothing than a world wide for-profit company.
invisible man
Mar 23 2008, 3:27 am
I agree 100%. The mystery of the universe and solar system and how earth created is still unknown. We are not alone.
Johnny Norfolk
Mar 23 2008, 9:45 am
When I first moved to Germay I opted out of paying any Church Tax. I moved into a small wine village. and at a local getogether I was introduced to various people one of which said to me in perfect English ' ah you are the one that does not pay church tax'. I was the only person in the village ( and probably still am ) not to pay the tax. I could see that life could be made difficult for you and that in Germany your personnal information is not private.
ryhntyntyn
Mar 23 2008, 9:51 am
QUOTE(pix @ Mar 20 2008, 3:05 pm)

I am a scientist not a believer and I want out. How do I do that?
Thanks.
Being a scientist and a believer are not mutually exclusive.
Allershausen
Mar 23 2008, 9:59 am
QUOTE(pix @ Mar 20 2008, 11:57 pm)

But you don't pay 9% of your income on that stupid car service, month by month. Right?
I think you may have missed Tfls point.
However, just for accuracy's sake you do not pay 9% of your income in church tax. It is 9% of your income tax, actually in Bayern and
Baden-Württemberg it's 8%. It's still a rip off and should be avoided at all costs.
Fallen Angel
Mar 23 2008, 10:08 am
QUOTE(pix @ Mar 20 2008, 11:57 pm)

But you don't pay 9% of your income on that stupid car service, month by month. Right?
Where are you getting that figure? I pay church tax. It's 1.1% of my gross income monthly. Or 1.9% of my net. Perhaps I shouldn't be posting this on a public forum... they might send me a bill.

QUOTE(pix @ Mar 20 2008, 11:57 pm)

I am not a believer, but for those who are God SHOULD love you the same, not based on the quantity on money you pay Him.
Or... you think that paying that STUPID tax will buy you a place in heaven?
I never heard a story about Jesus sitting at the door of the Church and forcing those who didn't paid enough to go back home.
I wouldn't like to be part of such a religion.
I don't understand why the churches here "require" their members to pay tax. Though, one should note that there are members who are exempt from paying any church tax. And you're free to go to church without actually signing up as a member. It seems to me a system where people give what they want to give or are able to give seems more appropriate. Church tax sends the message, especially to those who might be signed up with the church but have no connection to the church community, that the church is solely interested in how much money they can squeeze out of each member. And I refuse to believe that every single leader of every single church in this country has those sinister intentions.
QUOTE(pix @ Mar 20 2008, 11:57 pm)

Be wise and open minded. Church is nothing than a world wide for-profit company.
Bit dramatic, isn't it? I have more experience with churches back home, but they didn't focus purely on the cash. They operated on a donation basis, and were able to reduce costs and spending by the amount of people who donated their time. You could do with a dose of open-mindedness yourself. Though I admire your ability to shove all churches into one convenient "evil, greedy bastards" category.
Edit: Ah-- Allershausen has cleared up my church tax confusion. I forgot it was based on your
income tax. Still, it's peanuts really.
Pas
Mar 23 2008, 11:46 am
QUOTE(parnell @ Mar 20 2008, 3:47 pm)

I'd like to be an atheist , I just couldn't stand the dour arrogance that seems to come with it.
Glad to see that, although sarcasm may be missing from, TT irony isn't.
parnell
Mar 23 2008, 12:09 pm
As is rubbish punctuation.
Pas
Mar 23 2008, 12:10 pm
You have me on that.
Sinderbox
Mar 23 2008, 12:33 pm
QUOTE(Pas @ Mar 23 2008, 11:46 am)

Glad to see that, although sarcasm may be missing from, TT irony isn't.
QUOTE(parnell @ Mar 23 2008, 12:09 pm)

As is rubbish punctuation.
I thought as if,
trying he was,
some kind of Haiku, to do.
rick_de
Mar 23 2008, 1:04 pm
QUOTE(Johnny Norfolk @ Mar 23 2008, 9:45 am)

---------
I was introduced to various people one of which said to me in perfect English ' ah you are the one that does not pay church tax'.
--------
I could see that life could be made difficult for you and that in Germany your personnal information is not private.
What a bastard. I would liked to have said in reply: "And people like you are the reason I dont pay".
What about the much heralded German "Datenschutz" that they are always quacking on about?
QUOTE(rick_de @ Mar 23 2008, 1:04 pm)

What about the much heralded German "Datenschutz" that they are always quacking on about?
"Datenschutz" only applies when it suits people. It applies when they want to hide behind it & gets swept away when they don't...
Johnny Norfolk
Mar 24 2008, 12:23 am
Ric de
I did not let him get away with it, and went on to tell him how free we were in England. This was before Brown was PM.
I tried to explan that it would be seen as a personel choice and the state would have nothing to do with. However after 10 years of the Labour dictatorship I would not be sure about anything in England anymore as Labour is taking Britain back to a high tax enterpriseless country as it was before Thatcher.
QUOTE(ryhntyntyn @ Mar 23 2008, 9:51 am)

Being a scientist and a believer are not mutually exclusive.
Then you should tell me if the man was made from Adam or if it evolved from monkey.
By the way... nobody have found any trace of Adam's body but they have found lot of dinosaur bones.
Mariposa
Mar 24 2008, 2:32 am
Maybe Adam was a monkey.
Fastbucks
Mar 24 2008, 10:44 am
I told them I was an Independent Methodist . They said "a what?".
I said "it's a Methodist who's independent from all the other Methodists" and they said OK you don't have to pay, Sorted huh!
ryhntyntyn
Mar 24 2008, 1:10 pm
QUOTE(pix @ Mar 24 2008, 2:44 am)

Then you should tell me if the man was made from Adam or if it evolved from monkey.
By the way... nobody have found any trace of Adam's body but they have found lot of dinosaur bones.
I am not advocating any religious explanations for the existence of life. Science is simply not the opposite of religion, it should not serve as a substitute for religion. Science is a method. On God and religion, science itself and those speaking for science must remain neutral because science cannot answer the question. God cannot be proven or disproven. Religion and God is not a question for science but for philosophy.
You are viewing a low fidelity version of this page. Click to view
the full page.