OK, here's my critical review. Hessen State Opera is not exactly the big leagues so the talent level is never overwhelming and sometimes underwhelming. I thought the soprano seemed very seasoned compared to everyone else. Scarpia was a way better actor than a singer. That's not good. The Tenor was weak, clumsy, no acting skills, and no one even thought of applauding after recondita armonia. That's bad. Production values were underwhelming.
I wouldn't mind going again as the Theater is close for a lot of people, tickets are available and not too expensive, and there are enough watering holes in the neighborhood for drinks before/after. If someone wants to see better ((albeit more expensive) productions then Frankfurt is a goood call.
I believe Die Zauberflöte is coming up soon in Wiesbaden, BTW.