QUOTE (Hutcho @ Oct 15 2007, 10:47 am)

@Conquistador
My point is that someone sees that it's only 25% tax in country X but it's 40% here. However, in country X you have to pay health insurance and pension yourself, and they don't take that into consideration.
I know you have done the sums before for America, and overall the "taxes" are less than here, however still when you remove the cost of medical insurance and pension from the German system, it's seems to be not a lot higher for most people than in your previous example of America.
Hutcho, your point is understood; however, it really depends on the details of each individual situation. When I compare US and German 'taxes', I do account for the cost of health insurance as much as I can. As for removing the pension contributions from any calculation of after-tax salary, I think that is a huge mistake, given that you will not receive them for years, if at all (what if the non-EU citizen decides to stay >5 yrs.?). If a non-EU citizen starts working here today and does so for five years, the earliest one would get their portion of the pension contribution back is seven years from now. That amount must be discounted for inflation, and you must also take into account that any old-age pension received will be less because of these missing payments, if you do decide to leave Germany and apply for them. It is poor accounting to take the pension contributions out of any current calculations of after-tax and after-deduction salary, because you do not know for sure you will ever get it back, plus you aren't getting the amount of the pension deduction refunded to you in the current accounting period. If one wants to do an ex post facto adjustment once one receives the refund of the pension contributions years from now, fine, but not beforehand because it would overstate what actually makes its way into your bank account.
At any rate, we cannot ignore consumption taxes, especially in the case of Germany, where there is a high reliance upon them for tax revenue. I suggest that we work with actual numbers as much as possible to get a clear view.