TT logo
You are viewing a low-graphics version of this page. Click the headline to view full version:

Mid-air catch of a space probe

Those crazy Nasa guys

Toytown Germany > Discussion forum > Themes > Space
meckle
Hey look at this !!

BBC News: Scientists track incoming probe

Holy Cow! What are they going to do - stick a large fishing net out the window and catch it ??? Sounds like something from a Roadrunner cartoon !!!

DW - what will you wacky space engineers think of next ??
DrivinWest
This is a pretty cool mission; makes me think about moving to Southern California and working for the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (well, missions like this and the fact it is in SoCal!).
interplanetjanet
That's a bit nutty. Why didn't they just figure out a way to do it bouncing bubble style, like pathfinder?
DrivinWest
Pathfinder hit with some serious G's - around 18Gs if memory serves. If a regular parachute landing is enough to damage cargo then 18Gs is sure to do it.
VDB
It looks like it has more to do with unwanted contemination of the scientific samples, than overcoming the re-entry speed.
DrivinWest
I'm talking about impact with the surface. Pathfinder was dropped from altitude and hit the Mars surface VERY hard. The deceleration due to reetry in earth's atmosphere itself isn't very significant.
VDB
of course, but i'm talking about possible contamination when the probe hits the ground, or more likely the ocean. Since it had to collect the dust during it's mission it probably wasn't possible to hermitically seal the dust inside the probe, and so there's a good change of contamination on re-entry.
DrivinWest
Actually, just read it from the horse's mouth (www.nasa.gov). They're concerned about impact damage & contamination.
VDB
ok, that sounds about right.

Cool technique to use though, hope they shoot some film footage of it!
Jeeves
Impressive.
Hollywood turns out to be good for something ph34r.gif
interplanetjanet
Just received an email containing the following information:

The ESA TV Service will provide a live rebroadcast of NASA TV's coverage of
this first sample return from outer space since the Apollo era.

More background information can be found on
http://genesismission.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/return.html.

Transmission details:Eutelsat W1 @ 10 degrees East
Transponder B4 Middle Channel 2, vertical, SCPC
F=11.088,5 MHz, Sym rate=5.6320 MSym/sec
FEC 3/4

For further information, visit our website at http://television.esa.int.
DrivinWest
Live right now!
Keydeck
It's gone blue screen!

Back now biggrin.gif
Jimbo
This is thrilling - a small white dot traversing an entirely blue screen while lots of Americans say 'Negative drogue' 'Copy' and the like.

Seriously though - if the drogue shoot isn't out, does this mean it's gonna crash?

EDIT: Yes. it just crashed.
DrivinWest
No drogue. Shit.
Graham
another NASA cock up!
DrivinWest
Hopefully still usable particles regardless; the capsule is intact.
Grinner
NASA

Need Another Satellite Assembling tongue.gif
DrivinWest
QUOTE
another NASA cock up!

The day another space agency comes ever close to the successes of NASA, people have room to talk. It isn't brain surgery, it's rocket science; it's hard.
Keydeck
Funniest thing I've seen in ages...THWACK!!!

Jimbo
Hell of a shame actually, and no way am i gonna take a pop at NASA - I couldn't fly a paper aeroplane let alone a fucking rocket.
Have to say tho - I did love the quote at the end 'It's crashed!' 'What is the altitude?' 'Errr...ground level, sir.' haha
don_riina
QUOTE
I couldn't fly a paper aeroplane let alone a fucking rocket

Seems to me that flying a rocket only involves sitting in a weird uprighty chair. Not exactly a fucking challenging task. Unless you are pissed.
meckle
ok - I wasn't following this - whats a drogue

yeah shame it crashed - any chance they can get anything useful from it I wonder ? Must watch the news tonight to see the footage.
You are viewing a low fidelity version of this page. Click to view the full page.