QUOTE (Small Town Boy @ May 26 2006, 11:35 am)

My problem with ID cards is that they will cost a fortune - an absolute fortune - to implement but won't actually make any impact on their intended aim: namely to make Britain "more secure".
Agreed. But that is a problem with the current proposals and NOT the principle itself.
Personally I think the secutrity aspects aere overplayed as the entitlement to services is probably the key reason and key benefit from an ID card.
I would also note that the current fiasco where the home office cannot trace foreign former prisoners would have been neatly sewn up if ID cards had been in place.
QUOTE (Small Town Boy @ May 26 2006, 11:35 am)

I also find it extemely hypocritical of the government to be claiming, on the one hand, that they will not let terrorists succeed, while infringing our civil liberties on the other. ID cards are a waste of time and money; even New Labour knows this, but wants to be seen to be tough on terrorism.
Hmmm. Actually The Home Office, Department of Health and Department of Education have all been pushing for ID cards for generations ever since Churchill rather foolishly abolished the last ID card. Accounting for and reimbursing education and health and monitoring offenders are each problematic without an ID/entitlement card in place. The UK civil service can only look in envy at all our nnear European neighbours including Germany. Any government that takes office has been aware of this civil service demand but has also been painfully aware that politically it is a nonstarter with the hysterically illinformed libertarian bent of the UK population. Until now that is, terrorsim isn't the reason it is being implemented but it does provide a political excuse to implement the card with a minimum of public hostility.
QUOTE (Small Town Boy @ May 26 2006, 11:35 am)

If you think ID cards will be effective, perhaps consider the opinion of Frank Abagnale, the fraudster on whom the film Catch Me if You Can was based:
BBC News: Fighting back on ID theftDepends what you want them to be effective for. Personally I don't think they will inconvenience terroirists greatly. But an ID card would in the long term generate considerable savings in benefit fraud, health reimbursement, education reimbursement and policing.