YorkshireLad6
May 3 2006, 4:38 pm
QUOTE (lostmymojo @ May 3 2006, 2:21 pm)

A friend of mine drove through Austria without realizing that you had to buy one of these. He now has a bill for 400 EUR to show for it.
Was he caught red-handed in Austria, or did he subsequently get a letter back home (in Germany, I presume)
benpanter
May 3 2006, 4:41 pm
seeing as I know the guy too, to answer the various questions:
- He's been here under six months
- German registered car
- Received a letter in the post to current address in Germany
- Tried phoning, they're not interested in the "didn't know about it" excuse
Letter also offers a 1day, 8 hour jail sentence as an option...
Jeeves
May 3 2006, 4:42 pm
Ben is that "one day, i.e. 8 hours" or "one day plus 8 hours"?
benpanter
May 3 2006, 4:44 pm
I think it was 'plus' but I'm not sure.
Darkknight
May 3 2006, 5:04 pm
Hell, if there will be no record afterwords.. Why not go chill in a cell watch a bit of TV and have lunch, all paid for by the AT Govt..
Even better if they allow your SO to come for conjugal visits, like in Germany...
Hagar
May 5 2006, 11:08 am
Here's my take on the system. I understand that you need a reasonable fine to deter people from trying to evade the tax. Maybe 400 Euro for not having a ticket which costs 70 Euro / year is reasonable in this context, or maybe it is hiked up cos it brings in valuable money for the austrians, I don't know.
Thing is, of course, it isn't particularly reasonable if you were unaware of the whole thing (or if you mis-understood the expiry date like somebody earlier in this thread did). The signs say "Toll Sticker" in english, but do they inform you *in english* about how and where to obtain one? Or could you be forgiven for thinking that some Toll station is coming up where you will have to buy one? Most of us know the system either cos we worked it out for ourselves, heard about it from friends, or read about it here or in some guide book, but I bet there is a fair number each month who get the fine without knowingly having tried to escape the tax.
In the case of the guy in question whom I also know - he recently received the fine after stopping at an austrian rest-stop more than two months ago. He's been down to Italy several times since, with an extra 4 stops at rest stops in austria, so in theory he could be looking at a compounded fine of 2000 Euros. Surely you must have lived a good while in Germany to think that is a reasonable fine for doing something stupid?
MonksTown
May 5 2006, 11:25 am
Firstly, ignorance of the law is no a defence.
Given the road signs, the fact that the story is reguarly in the local papers, is common knowledge to just about everyone locally in Munich and is publicised on 101 tables and websites about driving in Europe then someone claiming they were unaware is on very thin ice.
Are the fines very high compared to the cost of the pickerl itself?
YES, deliberately so.
If the fine was say 100 Euros per offence then with the traffic and the what, 90 minute drive from Kiefersfelden to Brenner a lot of German motorists would take the risk cos it would pay for itself. But at EUR 400 they think twice and buy a pickerl.
Maybe the guy who drve 4 times to Italy will avoid a fine for the other transgressions. I hope so.
But wait till the Austrians learn off London and the RFID technology. Put a chip in the pickerl and sling a few number plate recognising cameras over the Autobahn at Kufstein and their computers can then spit out soon to be EU wide enforceable fines for every offence!
Hagar
May 5 2006, 1:46 pm
QUOTE (MonksTown @ May 5 2006, 11:25 am)

Given the road signs, the fact that the story is reguarly in the local papers, is common knowledge to just about everyone locally in Munich and is publicised on 101 tables and websites about driving in Europe then someone claiming they were unaware is on very thin ice.
First if you don't know any german let alone any locals, most of the above is pretty unhelpful. Though you're right that viamichelin.com would tell you. My point is still that it
does happen that people do this unintentionally, and in that respect the fine is clearly on the stiff side. So the system works fine for most people but it is an unreasonable fine for true ignorance. I think it fits with the german geist though - as long as you behave as you should and are as informed as you should be, you have nothing to be worried about...
QUOTE
But wait till the Austrians learn off London and the RFID technology. Put a chip in the pickerl and sling a few number plate recognising cameras over the Autobahn at Kufstein and their computers can then spit out soon to be EU wide enforceable fines for every offence!
If you're talking about the congestion charging - I would argue that you need to be a little more ignorant to make it into central London without noticing the CC signs. If the austrian tax sticker was as well marked (in an international language - i.e. English) there wouldn't be a problem.
MonksTown
May 5 2006, 2:01 pm
QUOTE (Hagar @ May 5 2006, 2:46 pm)

First if you don't know any german let alone any locals,
The AA and RAC sites and guides mention it too as does any guide book to Austria which you'd surely look at if you were so new you didn't know any locals or German.
Driving into Central London you see the "C" sign, driving into Austria you see the Vignette Symbol with afaik, "toll obligtory" which is in errrrrrm English. It's not a "german Geist" to have a igh toll, its to screw the Germans which Austrian coppers luv doing.
Hagar
May 5 2006, 2:25 pm
QUOTE (MonksTown @ May 5 2006, 2:01 pm)

The AA and RAC sites and guides mention it too as does any guide book to Austria which you'd surely look at if you were so new you didn't know any locals or German.
If you weren't going to Austria - merely passing through? Probably - not surely.
QUOTE
Driving into Central London you see the "C" sign, driving into Austria you see the Vignette Symbol with afaik, "toll obligtory" which is in errrrrrm English. It's not a "german Geist" to have a igh toll, its to screw the Germans which Austrian coppers luv doing.
We can keep this little argument going all day

- but my point is simply that it [it] does [/it] happen that people actually are ignorant about it, and that 400 Euro is excessive unless a person knew about it and decided to risk it. The fine in London is 100 pounds, which is reduced to 50 pounds upon prompt payment. A little more reasonable don't you think?
If you think 400 Euro is ok - then how about 2000 Euro? Is that ok too? If you extrapolate this in the extreme - I remember a Star-trek episode where they visited a planet which had the death penalty for even the slightest misdemeanors. Worked fine since everybody knew about it. Except for the "tourists";)
If the Austrians were interested in a fairer system couldn't they simply put up toll-booths (with chip-lanes so the regulars wouldn't have to queue) which would eliminate any such incidents. I reckon they're raking it in and see no reason to change their ways...
YorkshireLad6
May 5 2006, 2:34 pm
QUOTE (Hagar @ May 5 2006, 3:25 pm)

I reckon they're raking it in and see no reason to change their ways...
The perfect business case, and probably why the Austrians are considered the "Scots" of central Europe. Ignorance is no excuse. Thank heavens someone at least tells the Brits which side of the road to drive on in Europe...
MonksTown
May 8 2006, 9:34 am
Toll booths cost more than a vignette system to administer. The issue of transit and costs of traffic is so important to Austrians that they arranged a special proviso when they joined the EU that they were allowed to introduce tolls for their motorways.
I luv it when motorists from germany get their knickers in a twist over the pickerl and the highway police in Austria and then the local press starts fothing at the mouth. it's one of the TZ / AZ stock in trade stories that comes up at least once or twice a year.
sea-king
May 8 2006, 9:38 am
QUOTE (YorkshireLad6 @ May 5 2006, 2:34 pm)

The perfect business case, and probably why the Austrians are considered the "Scots" of central Europe. Ignorance is no excuse. Thank heavens someone at least tells the Brits which side of the road to drive on in Europe...
Lets not start on the Scots now

, we are miserable bastards I agree

, but putting us on a par with the Alpine Nazis is not going going to get you any free beer from me.
canaryman
May 8 2006, 9:50 am
I was pulled off the road for by a copper in Austria so he could check my vignette sticker. He was extremely confused when I spoke to him in English (I have German plates) and then even more confused when my wife showed him her German passport. He told me the reason (in English) and said it was ok to which I replied "I know" in German. He wasnt very happy but couldnt fine me!!
At the beginning of last year you could put the sticker in 3 different positions on the windscreen but they changed it on the last vignette to only accepting 2 positions on the windscreen. Guess what...yep, the Austrian coppers were then pulling people and fining them for putting it in last years "3rd" position which is no longer "approved".
Brilliant!!! (to collect extra money that is)
Johnny English
May 8 2006, 10:50 am
So what are the two allowed "vignette" positions please? Are there allowed permissions on motorbikes?
canaryman
May 8 2006, 10:59 am
The positioning is on the back of the vignette. I think it is the top left or bottom left of your windscreen. You used to be able to put it under your rear view mirror on the screen but the little positioning picture on the back of the new vignettes no longer gives you the option to stick it under the mirror
Sorry, but I dont know about motorbikes...what about on your visor or top of your helmet??
Johnny English
May 8 2006, 11:09 am
I am thinking it might be a bit sore stuck on the top of my helmet? Plus probably not enough surface area for good adhesion.
canaryman
May 8 2006, 11:11 am

was my first reaction to your post but thinking about it (which I shouldn't have done) I now think
MonksTown
May 8 2006, 11:12 am
JE, isn't it dangerous to put stickers on crash helmets?
Something about how the glue weakens them?
canaryman
May 8 2006, 11:16 am
Absolutely correct but I was only joking.
Jeeves
May 8 2006, 11:16 am
QUOTE (Johnny English @ May 8 2006, 11:50 am)

Are there allowed permissions on motorbikes?
You take your bike on the motorway? Strange person
When I lived in Austria and needed a vignette for the bike I stuck it on the front fork. That's probably disallowed now too though.
Johnny English
May 8 2006, 11:18 am
QUOTE
JE, isn't it dangerous to put stickers on crash helmets?
Something about how the glue weakens them?
There was a fuss about this a few years ago. I think it relates to the cheaper polycarbonate helmets. Also helmets are designed to run smoothly along the road so stickers do not help there either.
Yeti
May 8 2006, 11:26 am
Naw, they have special glue now that doesn't attack the plastics in the helmets. the thing is JE drives a "local bike for local people" so he probably doesn't need a sticker of an form down there.
UrbanAngel
Jul 3 2006, 3:42 pm
MikeEG
Jul 4 2006, 4:52 pm
I was caught last year without the vignette and was slapped with a 180 EUR fine. I was traveling from Switzerland to Munich and only had to travel about 20km through Austria so I thought I'd take a chance...
Apparently you only have to pay for the vignette if you use the motorways.
Viennamom
Jul 4 2006, 8:59 pm
You also need the vignette for the Schnellstrasses (highways.)
I think the vignette is fair. Austrians pay the extra tax money when they buy gas in Germany when they visit so it's only fair that the Germans pay for the vignette.
UrbanAngel
Jul 4 2006, 9:07 pm
I think a toll would be fairer if you're only cutting the corner of Austria.
Then again, at least in Austria you don't have to buy a whole year's vignette like you do in Switzerland for cars under 3.5 tonnes!
darmstadt
Jul 5 2006, 1:50 pm
I quite often have to get vignette for Austria and Switzerland but my Swiss customer told me a nice and easy trick. Cut a bit of clingfilm the same size as the vignette and stick the vignette to that and then stick the whole thing to the windscreen. This way you can share it between cars, friends and family. Apparently a lot of Swiss do that.
maverick
Jul 15 2006, 5:25 am
im driving thru austria at the end of the month, wats the vigenete thingy i need?
where can i get it?
im driving an english car, does it make a difference?
Jeeves
Jul 15 2006, 8:18 am
1) a motorway toll sticker for the inside of your windscreen
2) at the border
3) no
benpanter
Jul 15 2006, 9:51 am
QUOTE (Viennamom @ Jul 4 2006, 9:59 pm)

You also need the vignette for the Schnellstrasses (highways.)
I'm a bit lost as to the definition of highway in this context. Is a road numbered B### a highway? In the past I've not bothered to purchase except for on the autobahn
PES
Jul 15 2006, 10:07 am
QUOTE (maverick @ Jul 15 2006, 6:25 am)

im driving an english car, does it make a difference?
You are only allowed to drive backwards, in reverse, and you still need a vignette (but pastedn on your back window).
Wheel
Jul 15 2006, 11:00 am
QUOTE (benpanter @ Jul 15 2006, 10:51 am)

I'm a bit lost as to the definition of highway in this context. Is a road numbered B### a highway? In the past I've not bothered to purchase except for on the autobahn
Highway=motorway=autobahn. You only need vignettes for the autobahn.
UrbanAngel
Jul 15 2006, 11:18 am
Yes as the others said - when you're nearing the German/Austrian border, there should be a sign to turn right towards the 'Vignetteverkauf'. Follow this sign, and park you car along with the others, and go into a little office to buy the vignette.
YorkshireLad6
Jul 16 2006, 4:33 pm
You can also buy the Vignette at most filling stations, especially motorway service stations within 100-150km of the border, or
online from the ADAC. Some Autobahn stretches (e.g. the Brenner Autobahn) have additional toll fees. payable as you pass through them.
koorosh
Jul 16 2006, 7:46 pm
i think they check vignette randomly. My stupid GPS guided me into highway in austria and i had to drive a few kilometers before i get out of highway and go back to country roads.. But thanks god no body caught me.
sarabyrd
Jul 16 2006, 8:00 pm
Hot tip: Program the navigation system to plan the route without motorways next time. Or buy a vignette
YorkshireLad6
Jul 16 2006, 9:06 pm
Not only do you need a Vignette for the Autobahns, but one is also required to drive on the B302 (Wiener Nordrandstraße) and the B180 (Südumfahrung Landeck/Tirol)
MonksTown
Jul 17 2006, 9:05 am
QUOTE (koorosh @ Jul 16 2006, 8:46 pm)

My stupid GPS guided me into highway in austria and i had to drive a few kilometers before i get out of highway and go back to country roads..
Don't you ever watch the roadsigns?
If you didn't bother looking at the ones informing you that you were approaching a junction where you could be joining a vignette motorway I'd just hope you bother looking at the ones informing you thatyou are passing a school and to cut your speed!
boomtown_rat
Jul 17 2006, 9:16 am
QUOTE (Wheel @ Jul 15 2006, 12:00 pm)

Highway=motorway=autobahn. You only need vignettes for the autobahn.
you also need it for the schnellstraße (dual carriageways maybe?)
Jeeves
Jul 17 2006, 9:33 am
Monkstown I read it that he entered Austria on the autobahn and had no chance to exit until over the border. That could happen at Salzburg for instance (but not at Kufstein because the first 2 exits are vignette-free anyway).
canaryman
Jul 17 2006, 9:51 am
QUOTE (MonksTown @ Jul 17 2006, 10:05 am)

Don't you ever watch the roadsigns?
If you didn't bother looking at the ones informing you that you were approaching a junction where you could be joining a vignette motorway I'd just hope you bother looking at the ones informing you thatyou are passing a school and to cut your speed!
There is a huge difference between observing road safety signs and direction signs. I very rarely observe the direction signs on roads as I have sat nav but I read and observe the road safety signs. Do you actually drive?
Allershausen
Dec 13 2006, 12:43 pm
QUOTE (Jeeves @ Jul 17 2006, 9:33 am)

(but not at Kufstein because the first 2 exits are vignette-free anyway).
As an aside to the discussion about tolls in Germany I heard yesterday that this stretch of Autobahn will no longer be toll free in the New Year. Here's a link in German:
Bayern 3 News-vignette.
traveler007
Nov 6 2008, 10:24 am
hello everyone! We are about to make a trip from Germany to Verbier, Switzerland, in a German rental car, and our intention is to cross Austria from Fussen via Landeck to Scuol and farther. It's a small road almost all the way exept for some 15 km on the motorway just before Landeck. We figured out there's no need to buy a vignette for just 15 km, so we will try to avoid the motorway. There is a yellow road running parallel. Anyone has ever done this route? Do u know if there are any traps along that stretch of motorway? Any difficulties to stay off the motorway? Any confusing points?
You are viewing a low fidelity version of this page. Click to view
the full page.